How exceptional Garner became Everton's main man

What the report says

BBC Sport says James Garner has emerged as a central figure for Everton, with his work rate, ball recovery and passing making him a key player in David Moyes’ side. The article focuses on his performance in Everton’s goalless draw at Tottenham, where he was praised for breaking up attacks and helping his team compete against a stronger midfield.

Garner joined Everton from Manchester United in 2022 for an initial fee of £9m after a loan spell at Nottingham Forest. After a gradual settling-in period under Frank Lampard and Sean Dyche, the 2025-26 season is described as a turning point, with Garner missing only six minutes of Everton’s Premier League campaign and contributing goals, assists, tackles and chances created. Moyes has credited him with growing into more of a leader.

The report also notes that Garner’s form brought his first England cap in March, when he impressed in a friendly against Uruguay. England manager Thomas Tuchel later compared his style to Federico Valverde. Garner signed a new Everton contract in January running to 2030, and the club rejected a reported £65m Chelsea bid on deadline day, underlining how highly they value him.

BBC Sport adds that Garner’s versatility, including the ability to play in midfield or at full-back, is especially important because Everton have a thin senior squad and are missing other midfield options through injury.